
What It Means for Italian Citizenship Applicants
For thousands of families pursuing Italian citizenship by descent (jure sanguinis), one of the most frustrating legal obstacles in recent years has been the so-called “minor issue.”
Now, in a landmark decision, Italy’s Supreme Court (the Court of Cassation) has ruled that children who were already Italian citizens by birth do not automatically lose their Italian citizenship simply because a parent naturalized as a foreign citizen while they were still minors. The ruling overturns the restrictive interpretation that had caused many applications to be denied or delayed over the past several years.
What Was the “Minor Issue”?
Under Italy’s citizenship laws, Italian citizenship is generally passed from parent to child by bloodline (jure sanguinis).
For decades, the prevailing interpretation was that if an Italian parent became a citizen of another country before their child reached adulthood, the child did not necessarily lose Italian citizenship. However, beginning around 2023, a much stricter interpretation emerged. Some consulates and courts began rejecting applications if an ancestor had naturalized while their child was still a minor, arguing that citizenship had been interrupted in the family line.
This interpretation became known as the “minor issue” and affected thousands of descendants of Italian emigrants, particularly in the United States, Canada, Brazil, Argentina, and Australia.
The Supreme Court Has Now Clarified the Law
Italy’s United Sections of the Court of Cassation—the country’s highest authority on civil law interpretation—has now ruled that this restrictive reading was incorrect.
The Court held that children who acquired Italian citizenship by birth do not automatically lose it merely because a parent later acquires another nationality while the child is still under eighteen. In other words, the right to citizenship by descent remains intact in these circumstances.
This decision is expected to strengthen the legal position of many applicants whose cases had previously been rejected solely because of the “minor issue.”
Does This Overturn the Tajani Decree?
Not exactly—but it is an important development.
The Court’s decision concerns the judicial interpretation of historical Italian citizenship law, not the 2025 citizenship reforms commonly known as the Tajani Decree (later converted into Law 74/2025).
The Tajani reforms introduced broader restrictions on citizenship by descent, including new limits on transmission through later generations. Those provisions remain in force while separate legal challenges continue in the Italian courts and at the European level.
However, the Supreme Court’s ruling significantly weakens one of the legal theories that had been used to deny citizenship claims and restores a more traditional interpretation of Italian citizenship law. Many legal experts believe this is one of the most important citizenship decisions in recent years.
What Does This Mean for Applicants?
If your Italian citizenship application was denied because of the “minor issue,” or if you were told you were ineligible because an Italian ancestor naturalized while your next ancestor was still a minor, it may be worth speaking with an experienced Italian citizenship attorney about whether your case should be reviewed.
While every case is unique, this decision could reopen opportunities for many families who had previously believed their Italian line had been broken.
You’ll Still Need Sworn Translations
Regardless of how the law evolves, applicants must still provide accurate documentation proving each generation of their family line.
Most citizenship applications require sworn translations of documents such as:
- Birth certificates
- Marriage certificates
- Death certificates
- Divorce decrees
- Court records
- Naturalization records
- Name change documents
Translations must be accurate, complete, and accepted by the authority handling your application, whether that is an Italian court, an Italian consulate, or another government office.
Need Sworn Italian-English Translations?
At Hurley Certified Translation, we specialize in sworn Italian-English translations for Italian citizenship by descent applications. We work with applicants around the world and provide fast, accurate translations accepted for citizenship, immigration, and legal purposes.
If you’re preparing your citizenship application—or revisiting a case affected by the former “minor issue”—we’d be happy to help ensure your documents are translated accurately and professionally.
Contact us today for a free quote on your Italian citizenship document translations.